Commentary:

Carl's performance in Bounty mode shows a generally consistent win rate across different trophy ranges, with a slight upward trend as trophies increase. At lower trophies, his win rate hovers just above 50%, while it climbs notably at higher tiers, reaching over 70% in the highest bracket. This suggests that Carl may become more effective as players grow stronger and more experienced, but he doesn't stand out as a top-tier choice at any level. While he's not difficult to pick up, his overall performance indicates he may not be the best option for those aiming to climb quickly or dominate at higher levels.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Brawl Ball shows a gradual improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates rising from just under 50% at lower trophies to over 89% at the highest tiers. While he struggles slightly in the mid-tier ranges, his effectiveness becomes significantly stronger in higher-level matches. This suggests that Carl may be more rewarding for players who are already skilled and can take advantage of his late-game potential, but he might not be the easiest brawler to pick up for beginners due to his lower win rates at entry levels.

Commentary:

Carl performs consistently across all trophy buckets in Gem Grab, with win rates generally hovering just above or below 50%. His performance improves notably at higher trophy levels, reaching a win rate of 90.2% in the 1700+ trophy bucket. While Carl is not an overwhelming favorite in lower-tier matches, his effectiveness increases significantly as players become more skilled, suggesting that he may be better suited for advanced players looking to master his mechanics. Overall, Carl shows potential but requires a higher level of skill to excel.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Heist shows a generally consistent win rate across most trophy ranges, with a slight increase in win rate as trophies rise above 1000. At the highest trophy buckets, Carl performs notably well, with win rates exceeding 75% in the top tiers. This suggests that while Carl may not be the strongest choice for lower-tier players, he becomes increasingly effective at higher levels of play. His overall performance indicates that mastering Carl could be rewarding for experienced players, though he might not be the easiest brawler to pick up for newcomers due to his more moderate win rates in mid-tier ranges.

Commentary:

In HotZone, Carl's win rate fluctuates across different trophy brackets, with a generally consistent performance hovering around 45% to 53%. His highest win rate occurs in the 1100 trophy bucket at 61.8%, suggesting he can be effective for players in that range. However, his overall performance is not consistently strong, and no single trophy bracket shows a significantly high win rate above 62%. This indicates Carl may not be the most reliable choice for competitive play but could still be viable for casual or mid-tier players looking to experiment with different brawlers. Mastery might offer some edge in higher tiers, but his overall consistency is moderate at best.

Commentary:

Carl performs reasonably well in Knockout across most trophy ranges, with a win rate generally hovering around 50%. His performance peaks at higher trophies, where he achieves a win rate above 60% in the top tiers (1100+), suggesting that he can be effective for experienced players. However, his win rate dips slightly below 50% in lower and very high trophy brackets, indicating that he may not be the easiest brawler to pick up or master consistently across all skill levels.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Wipeout shows a generally consistent but not outstanding win rate across all trophy buckets, ranging from 43.5% to 55.6%. While he performs reasonably well in lower-tier matches and maintains a solid presence in higher tiers, his win rates rarely exceed 55%, indicating that he may not be the strongest choice for competitive play. His performance suggests that Carl is neither particularly easy nor especially difficult to pick up, but mastering him may not provide a significant edge over other brawlers in this mode.