Commentary:

Carl's performance in Bounty mode shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates climbing from 33.5% at lower trophies to a high of 75% at the highest tier. While his early-game win rate is below average, he becomes significantly stronger as players gain more experience and trophies. This suggests that Carl may be challenging to pick up initially but can become a strong choice for experienced players who can leverage his higher-tier performance. Overall, mastering Carl could lead to strong results in Bounty mode, especially at higher trophy levels.

Commentary:

Carl performs poorly in Brawl Ball at lower trophy levels, with win rates consistently below 50% until reaching around 1100 trophies. As his trophy count increases, his performance improves significantly, with win rates surpassing 65% at 1100 trophies and climbing to over 90% at the highest tiers. This suggests that Carl is not easy to pick up for casual players but can be highly effective once mastered, particularly in competitive play where his win rate becomes very strong.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Gem Grab shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates gradually rising from 40.2% at lower trophies to an impressive 92.9% among the highest ranked players. While Carl may struggle initially and is not a strong pick for beginners, he becomes significantly more effective as players gain experience and skill. This suggests that Carl can be worth mastering for those looking to climb in higher-tier play, though he may require time and practice to fully utilize his potential.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Heist shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates rising from 38.3% at lower trophies to over 80% in the highest tiers. While he starts off with a below-average win rate, his effectiveness becomes significantly stronger in higher-level play, suggesting that mastering Carl requires reaching higher trophy brackets where he excels. This indicates that Carl may be challenging to pick up initially but can become a powerful choice once players reach higher skill levels and understand his strengths in Heist.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Hot Zone shows a steady improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates gradually rising from 34.8% at lower trophies to a peak of 71.3% at the highest trophy bucket (1200). However, his win rate slightly declines again at the very top tier. While Carl becomes significantly more effective in higher-level matches, his overall performance remains inconsistent across different skill levels. This suggests that Carl may be challenging to master and perform reliably in lower-tier games but can become a strong pick for experienced players at the highest levels.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Knockout mode shows a gradual improvement as trophy levels increase, with win rates rising from 39.9% at lower trophies to over 80% at the highest tiers. While he struggles significantly at lower levels, his effectiveness becomes much stronger in higher-tier matches. This suggests that Carl may be challenging to pick up for beginners but can become a powerful choice once players reach higher skill levels and understand how to leverage his strengths effectively.

Commentary:

Carl's performance in Wipeout shows a steady increase in win rate as trophy level rises, peaking at 55.3% in the highest trophy bucket (1100+). However, his overall win rates remain below 50% across most tiers, with only slight improvements at higher levels. This suggests that while Carl can be effective for players reaching high trophies, he may not be the strongest choice for casual or mid-tier players. Mastery could provide an edge, but he might require more skill to consistently perform well compared to other brawlers.